Comments on: New wayfinding sign, more streetscape development

By: Another downtown Wayfinding sign installed - Locally Grown

Another downtown Wayfinding sign installed - Locally Grown — Thu, 08 May 2008 13:17:19 +0000

[...] downtown streetscape Wayfinding this week, this new one at the SW corner of Division and 2nd. (See this Oct. blog post about the first and this Sept blog post about the streetscape [...]

By: Sean Hayford O'Leary

Sean Hayford O'Leary — Wed, 14 Nov 2007 19:05:32 +0000

The signs could certainly be useful, but that prototype is pretty awful-looking. I don’t like the separation of brands between the City of Northfield and Explore Northfield™.

I’d much prefer something utilitarian with the city’s logo or no logo at all.

By: Griff Wigley

Griff Wigley — Wed, 14 Nov 2007 18:28:44 +0000

Christine, you’re right, that Appendix H starting on p. 86 is very small print. But most PDFs, including this one, allow you to increase the magnification of any page. The budget pages start to become readable at 150%. Try that and let me know if how it goes.

By: Christine Stanton

Christine Stanton — Wed, 14 Nov 2007 18:20:29 +0000

Griff, Is there any other way to view the final streetscape plan? In both the pdf and the slideshow options, the budget is too small to read. I would prefer not having to print it out to read it.

By: Jerry Bilek

Jerry Bilek — Wed, 14 Nov 2007 17:21:39 +0000

my understanding from the presentation is that nothing is final at this point. The plans are there to bring feedback. The consultant did stress the desire to make the rive accessible via stairs.

By: Christine Stanton

Christine Stanton — Wed, 14 Nov 2007 05:20:47 +0000

Is the rounded stair canoe landing part of the final plan? In one picture it shows straight stairs, but I like the rounded ones shown in the appendix. They would even be a nice place to sit and enjoy the river. The idea of a canoe landing is exciting! I wish someone would open a rental place that would also transport you upstream.

It would be neat to have a sign that talked about the history of the Cannon River originally being named the “Canoe River” somewhere near the landing. Maybe we could then consider it an investment in “human capital,” as it would be educational.

By: Griff Wigley

Griff Wigley — Tue, 13 Nov 2007 22:12:04 +0000

I’ve put up the 90-page final streetscape plan on the NDDC blog here, both in PDF and slideshow format. Yes, I charged NDDC for my time, but it was considerably less than $85,000.

By: Northfield Downtown Development Corporation » Weblog » Downtown streetscape plan - final document

Tue, 13 Nov 2007 22:10:28 +0000

[...] Ross’ blog post here on the NDDC blog as well a blog post on our Locally Grown that discussed the [...]

By: Two Opportunities to Comment on Streetscape Plans and Projects - Locally Grown

Two Opportunities to Comment on Streetscape Plans and Projects - Locally Grown — Mon, 05 Nov 2007 18:35:40 +0000

[...] known as Streetscape. His photos have included the Library Plaza, the Riverwalk Arches, and the Parking Lot Screening. All of these pieces are part of a larger scale and longer term effort to visually enhance our [...]

By: Randy Jennings

Randy Jennings — Sun, 04 Nov 2007 17:11:56 +0000

I am not aware of any plans to create such an archive, but we (Neuger Communications Group) have only been involved in the wayfinding project, and can’t speak to the direction of the overall streetscape program. The effort to tie the various streetscape elements together through architectural motifs was already on the table as a goal of the project when we became involved, so I can’t even tell you who had the original idea. Maybe Howard Merriam, maybe John Slack at Bonestroo, maybe Spencer Jones, maybe Joel Wallinski, or maybe it came out of the whole streetscape task force. We simply moved it forward by using Spencer’s fence design as the general shape of the wrought iron caps on the signs. Whether the fence design came before the arches, or vice versa, I couldn’t say…

Randy

By: Griff Wigley

Griff Wigley — Sun, 04 Nov 2007 13:54:48 +0000

Randy, thanks for the update and explanation. Helps a lot.

Is there or will there be a webpage where the whole streetscape project/rationale is explained in detail? I think it would especially help to have more info on the historical tie-ins to the old bridges with old photos.

By: Bright Spencer

Bright Spencer — Thu, 01 Nov 2007 15:06:30 +0000

I like the poles and signage designs in and of themselves, but don’t get the
inherent connection between the town and them, even though I remember a description given which ties in the river. I also have a slight objection to the more or less masculine nature of the work, with no feminine balance, unless you count the actual thru way as such.

By: Randy Jennings

Randy Jennings — Thu, 01 Nov 2007 01:44:59 +0000

Thanks to Ross for pulling over the northfield.org comment about the wayfinding sign now hanging on 4th Street. I hadn’t realized there was an LG thread on this…

As noted, sign now hanging is a prototype to evaluate whether or not the sign is the right size. (It was designed for the corner of 4th and Division, not mid-block, but this was the closet light pole.) The final signs will be executed in wrought iron and metal panels.

What looks good in a design, and even as a mock-up hanging indoors, now looks small when installed. We’re trying to balance the readability issues Bright describes in post #3, with not wanting to be too obtrusive in placing these wayfinding signs in the historic district. Visible to visitors, but after a short period of time, nearly invisible to residents.

To further Philip’s comment, as the elements of the streetscape improvements roll out, I think we’ll all appreciate the thought that has gone into the various parts. Over the past few years, the mayor, council members, city staff, volunteers on the Mayor’s Streetscape Task Force and various designers, planners and others have done a nice job integrating a few key motifs across the projects. For example, the wrought iron bracket of the wayfinding signs is based on Spencer Jones’ designs for wrought iron fencing around city parking lots. In the end, a visitor to town might not notice every element, but the coherence of the designs, materials, colors and styles will communicate an aesthetic sensibility, a sense of purpose and a welcome that will reflect well on Northfield.

Randy

By: Philip Spensley

Philip Spensley — Wed, 31 Oct 2007 18:00:14 +0000

I begin to see the logic and the appeal… railings and the signs and the arches…same motif, same color scheme…eventually will create a unified aesthetic throughout the downtown. I like it and I look forward to further installations.

The only unpleasant aspect of the picture of the sign is the prominence of the parking regulations sign right next to it…really detracts from the sign I think. What a pity. Can we find a way to get rid of these ugly aspects while introducing the more eye pleasing ones? Will motorists take all sorts of scabrous liberties if we don’t limit them to two hours? Do we really really need parking limits downtown? But if we do, need those signs be so prominent? Could they be on the buildings, maybe, so from the street they’d be visible (for the drivers) but not visible while walking down the street?

But…more my point…thanks to all those responsible for the streetscape improvements so far.

By: Bill Ostrem

Bill Ostrem — Wed, 31 Oct 2007 15:27:32 +0000

I applaud the installation of the wayfinding sign. It will be a nice aid to visitors who want to walk around town.

By: Ross Currier

Ross Currier — Wed, 31 Oct 2007 01:24:58 +0000

Bright -

Randy Jennings commented on the NDDC site:

http://nddc.org/weblog/post/876/

To quote him about size:

“The sign on 4th Street is just a prototype to evaluate whether or not the sign is an appropriate size when installed.”

- Ross

By: Bright Spencer

Bright Spencer — Wed, 31 Oct 2007 00:55:13 +0000

Just saw the wayfarer signs as we were exiting Mandarin Garden. Well, I saw it,
and could barely read the wording, confessing that I don’t wear my walking glasses, cuz I only need them to read smallish writing. Well, I knew what the words on the sign said without actually seeing them clearly. I asked dh what he thought of the sign, and he said, “what sign?” while looking over in that general direction. Then he said he thought it was fine and that he could read it well.
I wonder how many people are like me and wandering around without thier
full 20/20 vision. I think quite a few, and as a result, I think a few of the elders
will miss that sign altogether. If you did move the two hour parking sign, you
might not look up to see the rather dull small sign.
Sorry to be so criitcal, but I have some experience with signage and it’s visibility, and find this to be another example of too little visibility for some of
our visitors.

By: Northfield Downtown Development Corporation » Weblog » 5th and Water Street Reconstruction Project to be Discussed at Forum

Tue, 30 Oct 2007 16:20:07 +0000

[...] projects are just more recent examples of the on-going Streetscape Plan, work financed by residuals generated by the Downtown TIF [...]

By: Kurt Larson

Kurt Larson — Tue, 30 Oct 2007 14:43:36 +0000

I have been watching the progress these last few weeks on the corner work at Mn Hwy 3 and the South Water parking lot. If you have not checked it out I would suggest doing so. The stone work on the walls is great, the bridge theme of the fencing is suttle and seems to work well.
On the first day of the work they spaded out the only tree left after the hwy reconstruction project. I was dissappointed, but now I see they have planted several new trees. A fair trade by far. The old tree was pretty big but the new ones will be nice, unless you think size does matter.
Also, the new walls take care of the need for a new skate board park, the kids should love it.